Hardware Requirement for Movie Capture and Editing



Peter
07-09-2005, 10:35 PM
I am planning to get a PC to do some occasional video capturing and editing
from my miniDV tapes. Will the following spec suffice for such a job:

Pentium 4 3.0Ghz, 512 RAM with on-board graphics memory (up to 128MB).
Specifically, I would like to know do I really need a separate graphics card
instead of the integrated one? This is what the salesman trying to sell me.

Thanks for any advise in advance.

Wojo
07-09-2005, 10:35 PM
If your current graphics card is 128MB I see no reason to purchase a
different one at this point. I do a lot of video editing and I only have a
64MB graphics card and it works just fine.
If you end up doing a lot of video editing the things I would look at first
are:
1 - Additional memory - 512 is ok but 1024 is much much better and memory is
cheap
2 - The size of the HDD - Video clips, especially when rendered to DV-AVI,
take a lot of space plus you need a place to store them until projects are
finished etc... I personally have two 160Gig HDD's in my system but that is
likely overkill for most.
3 - Make sure your computer has a DVD burner and decent DVD authoring
software (there's a list of quite a few different programs I have worked
with on my website in the "DVD Programs" section. Even if you don't think
you will be making DVD's I assure you once you start video editing you will
be hooked and it won't be long before your making DVD's and using DVD disks
as storage for seldom used clips etc...
--
Wojo
www.remember-christopher.dostweb.com/Wojo's_Place/

"Peter" <Peter@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in message
news:E486BC99-CAC0-476C-A10B-8C98223CE5A9@microsoft.com...
>I am planning to get a PC to do some occasional video capturing and editing
> from my miniDV tapes. Will the following spec suffice for such a job:
>
> Pentium 4 3.0Ghz, 512 RAM with on-board graphics memory (up to 128MB).
> Specifically, I would like to know do I really need a separate graphics
> card
> instead of the integrated one? This is what the salesman trying to sell
> me.
>
> Thanks for any advise in advance.

Peter
07-09-2005, 10:35 PM
Thanks very much for the reply Wojo. Are you saying the on-board (integrated)
graphics with up to 128MB of memeory is sufficient? Or are you assuming a
dedicated grahic card? Also, would you recommend MS Movie Maker for a novice?
I read from this forum that this is not the easiest tool to use. thanks.

"Wojo" wrote:

> If your current graphics card is 128MB I see no reason to purchase a
> different one at this point. I do a lot of video editing and I only have a
> 64MB graphics card and it works just fine.
> If you end up doing a lot of video editing the things I would look at first
> are:
> 1 - Additional memory - 512 is ok but 1024 is much much better and memory is
> cheap
> 2 - The size of the HDD - Video clips, especially when rendered to DV-AVI,
> take a lot of space plus you need a place to store them until projects are
> finished etc... I personally have two 160Gig HDD's in my system but that is
> likely overkill for most.
> 3 - Make sure your computer has a DVD burner and decent DVD authoring
> software (there's a list of quite a few different programs I have worked
> with on my website in the "DVD Programs" section. Even if you don't think
> you will be making DVD's I assure you once you start video editing you will
> be hooked and it won't be long before your making DVD's and using DVD disks
> as storage for seldom used clips etc...
> --
> Wojo
> www.remember-christopher.dostweb.com/Wojo's_Place/
>
> "Peter" <Peter@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in message
> news:E486BC99-CAC0-476C-A10B-8C98223CE5A9@microsoft.com...
> >I am planning to get a PC to do some occasional video capturing and editing
> > from my miniDV tapes. Will the following spec suffice for such a job:
> >
> > Pentium 4 3.0Ghz, 512 RAM with on-board graphics memory (up to 128MB).
> > Specifically, I would like to know do I really need a separate graphics
> > card
> > instead of the integrated one? This is what the salesman trying to sell
> > me.
> >
> > Thanks for any advise in advance.
>
>
>

Wojo
07-09-2005, 10:35 PM
I am saying the on-board 128MB is sufficient for now. Upgrading later may be
something you want to do but not because of the 128MB so much as the quality
of the card which, of course we don't know yet, but for now I would say
don't waste your money.
And yes I would definitely say WMM is the perfect video editing tool for a
novice.
Yes if you read this forum there are many people that have problems but
there are also solutions. You will also read that many people posting their
problems here didn't read through the forum first or they would have seen
there problem, in most cases, addressed and fixed many times in the past.
As you familiarize yourself with WMM I guarantee you will add other tools to
your video editing software other than WMM but I would bet you will still
use it along with these other tools. I have many different programs I use
for different things but usually put them together with WMM.

--
Wojo
www.remember-christopher.dostweb.com/Wojo's_Place/

"Peter" <Peter@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in message
news:AB7D99A8-F3E8-4672-B884-458EFD131060@microsoft.com...
> Thanks very much for the reply Wojo. Are you saying the on-board
> (integrated)
> graphics with up to 128MB of memeory is sufficient? Or are you assuming a
> dedicated grahic card? Also, would you recommend MS Movie Maker for a
> novice?
> I read from this forum that this is not the easiest tool to use. thanks.
>
> "Wojo" wrote:
>
>> If your current graphics card is 128MB I see no reason to purchase a
>> different one at this point. I do a lot of video editing and I only have
>> a
>> 64MB graphics card and it works just fine.
>> If you end up doing a lot of video editing the things I would look at
>> first
>> are:
>> 1 - Additional memory - 512 is ok but 1024 is much much better and memory
>> is
>> cheap
>> 2 - The size of the HDD - Video clips, especially when rendered to
>> DV-AVI,
>> take a lot of space plus you need a place to store them until projects
>> are
>> finished etc... I personally have two 160Gig HDD's in my system but that
>> is
>> likely overkill for most.
>> 3 - Make sure your computer has a DVD burner and decent DVD authoring
>> software (there's a list of quite a few different programs I have worked
>> with on my website in the "DVD Programs" section. Even if you don't think
>> you will be making DVD's I assure you once you start video editing you
>> will
>> be hooked and it won't be long before your making DVD's and using DVD
>> disks
>> as storage for seldom used clips etc...
>> --
>> Wojo
>> www.remember-christopher.dostweb.com/Wojo's_Place/
>>
>> "Peter" <Peter@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in message
>> news:E486BC99-CAC0-476C-A10B-8C98223CE5A9@microsoft.com...
>> >I am planning to get a PC to do some occasional video capturing and
>> >editing
>> > from my miniDV tapes. Will the following spec suffice for such a job:
>> >
>> > Pentium 4 3.0Ghz, 512 RAM with on-board graphics memory (up to 128MB).
>> > Specifically, I would like to know do I really need a separate graphics
>> > card
>> > instead of the integrated one? This is what the salesman trying to sell
>> > me.
>> >
>> > Thanks for any advise in advance.
>>
>>
>>

Peter
07-09-2005, 10:35 PM
Thanks so much fot the speedy response Wojo. The really helps. At least I
know I don't have to waste the money on the graphics card which I may not
need later. One last "stupid" question, are you from Microsoft or affliated
with Uncle Bill?

Thanks.

"Wojo" wrote:

> I am saying the on-board 128MB is sufficient for now. Upgrading later may be
> something you want to do but not because of the 128MB so much as the quality
> of the card which, of course we don't know yet, but for now I would say
> don't waste your money.
> And yes I would definitely say WMM is the perfect video editing tool for a
> novice.
> Yes if you read this forum there are many people that have problems but
> there are also solutions. You will also read that many people posting their
> problems here didn't read through the forum first or they would have seen
> there problem, in most cases, addressed and fixed many times in the past.
> As you familiarize yourself with WMM I guarantee you will add other tools to
> your video editing software other than WMM but I would bet you will still
> use it along with these other tools. I have many different programs I use
> for different things but usually put them together with WMM.
>
> --
> Wojo
> www.remember-christopher.dostweb.com/Wojo's_Place/
>
> "Peter" <Peter@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in message
> news:AB7D99A8-F3E8-4672-B884-458EFD131060@microsoft.com...
> > Thanks very much for the reply Wojo. Are you saying the on-board
> > (integrated)
> > graphics with up to 128MB of memeory is sufficient? Or are you assuming a
> > dedicated grahic card? Also, would you recommend MS Movie Maker for a
> > novice?
> > I read from this forum that this is not the easiest tool to use. thanks.
> >
> > "Wojo" wrote:
> >
> >> If your current graphics card is 128MB I see no reason to purchase a
> >> different one at this point. I do a lot of video editing and I only have
> >> a
> >> 64MB graphics card and it works just fine.
> >> If you end up doing a lot of video editing the things I would look at
> >> first
> >> are:
> >> 1 - Additional memory - 512 is ok but 1024 is much much better and memory
> >> is
> >> cheap
> >> 2 - The size of the HDD - Video clips, especially when rendered to
> >> DV-AVI,
> >> take a lot of space plus you need a place to store them until projects
> >> are
> >> finished etc... I personally have two 160Gig HDD's in my system but that
> >> is
> >> likely overkill for most.
> >> 3 - Make sure your computer has a DVD burner and decent DVD authoring
> >> software (there's a list of quite a few different programs I have worked
> >> with on my website in the "DVD Programs" section. Even if you don't think
> >> you will be making DVD's I assure you once you start video editing you
> >> will
> >> be hooked and it won't be long before your making DVD's and using DVD
> >> disks
> >> as storage for seldom used clips etc...
> >> --
> >> Wojo
> >> www.remember-christopher.dostweb.com/Wojo's_Place/
> >>
> >> "Peter" <Peter@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in message
> >> news:E486BC99-CAC0-476C-A10B-8C98223CE5A9@microsoft.com...
> >> >I am planning to get a PC to do some occasional video capturing and
> >> >editing
> >> > from my miniDV tapes. Will the following spec suffice for such a job:
> >> >
> >> > Pentium 4 3.0Ghz, 512 RAM with on-board graphics memory (up to 128MB).
> >> > Specifically, I would like to know do I really need a separate graphics
> >> > card
> >> > instead of the integrated one? This is what the salesman trying to sell
> >> > me.
> >> >
> >> > Thanks for any advise in advance.
> >>
> >>
> >>
>
>
>

Peter
07-09-2005, 10:35 PM
One very important question I forgot to ask earlier is do you need a video
capture card if you have a firewall port to capture video from miniDV?

"Peter" wrote:

> Thanks so much fot the speedy response Wojo. The really helps. At least I
> know I don't have to waste the money on the graphics card which I may not
> need later. One last "stupid" question, are you from Microsoft or affliated
> with Uncle Bill?
>
> Thanks.
>
> "Wojo" wrote:
>
> > I am saying the on-board 128MB is sufficient for now. Upgrading later may be
> > something you want to do but not because of the 128MB so much as the quality
> > of the card which, of course we don't know yet, but for now I would say
> > don't waste your money.
> > And yes I would definitely say WMM is the perfect video editing tool for a
> > novice.
> > Yes if you read this forum there are many people that have problems but
> > there are also solutions. You will also read that many people posting their
> > problems here didn't read through the forum first or they would have seen
> > there problem, in most cases, addressed and fixed many times in the past.
> > As you familiarize yourself with WMM I guarantee you will add other tools to
> > your video editing software other than WMM but I would bet you will still
> > use it along with these other tools. I have many different programs I use
> > for different things but usually put them together with WMM.
> >
> > --
> > Wojo
> > www.remember-christopher.dostweb.com/Wojo's_Place/
> >
> > "Peter" <Peter@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in message
> > news:AB7D99A8-F3E8-4672-B884-458EFD131060@microsoft.com...
> > > Thanks very much for the reply Wojo. Are you saying the on-board
> > > (integrated)
> > > graphics with up to 128MB of memeory is sufficient? Or are you assuming a
> > > dedicated grahic card? Also, would you recommend MS Movie Maker for a
> > > novice?
> > > I read from this forum that this is not the easiest tool to use. thanks.
> > >
> > > "Wojo" wrote:
> > >
> > >> If your current graphics card is 128MB I see no reason to purchase a
> > >> different one at this point. I do a lot of video editing and I only have
> > >> a
> > >> 64MB graphics card and it works just fine.
> > >> If you end up doing a lot of video editing the things I would look at
> > >> first
> > >> are:
> > >> 1 - Additional memory - 512 is ok but 1024 is much much better and memory
> > >> is
> > >> cheap
> > >> 2 - The size of the HDD - Video clips, especially when rendered to
> > >> DV-AVI,
> > >> take a lot of space plus you need a place to store them until projects
> > >> are
> > >> finished etc... I personally have two 160Gig HDD's in my system but that
> > >> is
> > >> likely overkill for most.
> > >> 3 - Make sure your computer has a DVD burner and decent DVD authoring
> > >> software (there's a list of quite a few different programs I have worked
> > >> with on my website in the "DVD Programs" section. Even if you don't think
> > >> you will be making DVD's I assure you once you start video editing you
> > >> will
> > >> be hooked and it won't be long before your making DVD's and using DVD
> > >> disks
> > >> as storage for seldom used clips etc...
> > >> --
> > >> Wojo
> > >> www.remember-christopher.dostweb.com/Wojo's_Place/
> > >>
> > >> "Peter" <Peter@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in message
> > >> news:E486BC99-CAC0-476C-A10B-8C98223CE5A9@microsoft.com...
> > >> >I am planning to get a PC to do some occasional video capturing and
> > >> >editing
> > >> > from my miniDV tapes. Will the following spec suffice for such a job:
> > >> >
> > >> > Pentium 4 3.0Ghz, 512 RAM with on-board graphics memory (up to 128MB).
> > >> > Specifically, I would like to know do I really need a separate graphics
> > >> > card
> > >> > instead of the integrated one? This is what the salesman trying to sell
> > >> > me.
> > >> >
> > >> > Thanks for any advise in advance.
> > >>
> > >>
> > >>
> >
> >
> >

Wojo
07-09-2005, 10:35 PM
Nope, just somebody interested in video editing, computers in general, and
especially DVD creation.

"Peter" <Peter@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in message
news:FED78F91-64D1-42D6-8516-7FB75F67C077@microsoft.com...
> Thanks so much fot the speedy response Wojo. The really helps. At least I
> know I don't have to waste the money on the graphics card which I may not
> need later. One last "stupid" question, are you from Microsoft or
> affliated
> with Uncle Bill?
>
> Thanks.
>
> "Wojo" wrote:
>
>> I am saying the on-board 128MB is sufficient for now. Upgrading later may
>> be
>> something you want to do but not because of the 128MB so much as the
>> quality
>> of the card which, of course we don't know yet, but for now I would say
>> don't waste your money.
>> And yes I would definitely say WMM is the perfect video editing tool for
>> a
>> novice.
>> Yes if you read this forum there are many people that have problems but
>> there are also solutions. You will also read that many people posting
>> their
>> problems here didn't read through the forum first or they would have seen
>> there problem, in most cases, addressed and fixed many times in the past.
>> As you familiarize yourself with WMM I guarantee you will add other tools
>> to
>> your video editing software other than WMM but I would bet you will still
>> use it along with these other tools. I have many different programs I use
>> for different things but usually put them together with WMM.
>>
>> --
>> Wojo
>> www.remember-christopher.dostweb.com/Wojo's_Place/
>>
>> "Peter" <Peter@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in message
>> news:AB7D99A8-F3E8-4672-B884-458EFD131060@microsoft.com...
>> > Thanks very much for the reply Wojo. Are you saying the on-board
>> > (integrated)
>> > graphics with up to 128MB of memeory is sufficient? Or are you assuming
>> > a
>> > dedicated grahic card? Also, would you recommend MS Movie Maker for a
>> > novice?
>> > I read from this forum that this is not the easiest tool to use.
>> > thanks.
>> >
>> > "Wojo" wrote:
>> >
>> >> If your current graphics card is 128MB I see no reason to purchase a
>> >> different one at this point. I do a lot of video editing and I only
>> >> have
>> >> a
>> >> 64MB graphics card and it works just fine.
>> >> If you end up doing a lot of video editing the things I would look at
>> >> first
>> >> are:
>> >> 1 - Additional memory - 512 is ok but 1024 is much much better and
>> >> memory
>> >> is
>> >> cheap
>> >> 2 - The size of the HDD - Video clips, especially when rendered to
>> >> DV-AVI,
>> >> take a lot of space plus you need a place to store them until projects
>> >> are
>> >> finished etc... I personally have two 160Gig HDD's in my system but
>> >> that
>> >> is
>> >> likely overkill for most.
>> >> 3 - Make sure your computer has a DVD burner and decent DVD authoring
>> >> software (there's a list of quite a few different programs I have
>> >> worked
>> >> with on my website in the "DVD Programs" section. Even if you don't
>> >> think
>> >> you will be making DVD's I assure you once you start video editing you
>> >> will
>> >> be hooked and it won't be long before your making DVD's and using DVD
>> >> disks
>> >> as storage for seldom used clips etc...
>> >> --
>> >> Wojo
>> >> www.remember-christopher.dostweb.com/Wojo's_Place/
>> >>
>> >> "Peter" <Peter@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in message
>> >> news:E486BC99-CAC0-476C-A10B-8C98223CE5A9@microsoft.com...
>> >> >I am planning to get a PC to do some occasional video capturing and
>> >> >editing
>> >> > from my miniDV tapes. Will the following spec suffice for such a
>> >> > job:
>> >> >
>> >> > Pentium 4 3.0Ghz, 512 RAM with on-board graphics memory (up to
>> >> > 128MB).
>> >> > Specifically, I would like to know do I really need a separate
>> >> > graphics
>> >> > card
>> >> > instead of the integrated one? This is what the salesman trying to
>> >> > sell
>> >> > me.
>> >> >
>> >> > Thanks for any advise in advance.
>> >>
>> >>
>> >>
>>
>>
>>

Wojo
07-09-2005, 10:35 PM
You shouldn't. If you have the firewire port then you should be video
capture ready.
I don't work with video capturing myself yet, my camera records right to CD,
but AFAIK the firewire card should be all you need.

"Peter" <Peter@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in message
news:97A2F4C4-56A6-4F22-82AC-983E124BC3B5@microsoft.com...
> One very important question I forgot to ask earlier is do you need a video
> capture card if you have a firewall port to capture video from miniDV?
>
> "Peter" wrote:
>
>> Thanks so much fot the speedy response Wojo. The really helps. At least I
>> know I don't have to waste the money on the graphics card which I may not
>> need later. One last "stupid" question, are you from Microsoft or
>> affliated
>> with Uncle Bill?
>>
>> Thanks.
>>
>> "Wojo" wrote:
>>
>> > I am saying the on-board 128MB is sufficient for now. Upgrading later
>> > may be
>> > something you want to do but not because of the 128MB so much as the
>> > quality
>> > of the card which, of course we don't know yet, but for now I would say
>> > don't waste your money.
>> > And yes I would definitely say WMM is the perfect video editing tool
>> > for a
>> > novice.
>> > Yes if you read this forum there are many people that have problems but
>> > there are also solutions. You will also read that many people posting
>> > their
>> > problems here didn't read through the forum first or they would have
>> > seen
>> > there problem, in most cases, addressed and fixed many times in the
>> > past.
>> > As you familiarize yourself with WMM I guarantee you will add other
>> > tools to
>> > your video editing software other than WMM but I would bet you will
>> > still
>> > use it along with these other tools. I have many different programs I
>> > use
>> > for different things but usually put them together with WMM.
>> >
>> > --
>> > Wojo
>> > www.remember-christopher.dostweb.com/Wojo's_Place/
>> >
>> > "Peter" <Peter@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in message
>> > news:AB7D99A8-F3E8-4672-B884-458EFD131060@microsoft.com...
>> > > Thanks very much for the reply Wojo. Are you saying the on-board
>> > > (integrated)
>> > > graphics with up to 128MB of memeory is sufficient? Or are you
>> > > assuming a
>> > > dedicated grahic card? Also, would you recommend MS Movie Maker for a
>> > > novice?
>> > > I read from this forum that this is not the easiest tool to use.
>> > > thanks.
>> > >
>> > > "Wojo" wrote:
>> > >
>> > >> If your current graphics card is 128MB I see no reason to purchase a
>> > >> different one at this point. I do a lot of video editing and I only
>> > >> have
>> > >> a
>> > >> 64MB graphics card and it works just fine.
>> > >> If you end up doing a lot of video editing the things I would look
>> > >> at
>> > >> first
>> > >> are:
>> > >> 1 - Additional memory - 512 is ok but 1024 is much much better and
>> > >> memory
>> > >> is
>> > >> cheap
>> > >> 2 - The size of the HDD - Video clips, especially when rendered to
>> > >> DV-AVI,
>> > >> take a lot of space plus you need a place to store them until
>> > >> projects
>> > >> are
>> > >> finished etc... I personally have two 160Gig HDD's in my system but
>> > >> that
>> > >> is
>> > >> likely overkill for most.
>> > >> 3 - Make sure your computer has a DVD burner and decent DVD
>> > >> authoring
>> > >> software (there's a list of quite a few different programs I have
>> > >> worked
>> > >> with on my website in the "DVD Programs" section. Even if you don't
>> > >> think
>> > >> you will be making DVD's I assure you once you start video editing
>> > >> you
>> > >> will
>> > >> be hooked and it won't be long before your making DVD's and using
>> > >> DVD
>> > >> disks
>> > >> as storage for seldom used clips etc...
>> > >> --
>> > >> Wojo
>> > >> www.remember-christopher.dostweb.com/Wojo's_Place/
>> > >>
>> > >> "Peter" <Peter@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in message
>> > >> news:E486BC99-CAC0-476C-A10B-8C98223CE5A9@microsoft.com...
>> > >> >I am planning to get a PC to do some occasional video capturing and
>> > >> >editing
>> > >> > from my miniDV tapes. Will the following spec suffice for such a
>> > >> > job:
>> > >> >
>> > >> > Pentium 4 3.0Ghz, 512 RAM with on-board graphics memory (up to
>> > >> > 128MB).
>> > >> > Specifically, I would like to know do I really need a separate
>> > >> > graphics
>> > >> > card
>> > >> > instead of the integrated one? This is what the salesman trying to
>> > >> > sell
>> > >> > me.
>> > >> >
>> > >> > Thanks for any advise in advance.
>> > >>
>> > >>
>> > >>
>> >
>> >
>> >


Hardware Requirement for Movie Capture and Editing